Building trust: making welfare and employment support work for people living with mental illness

One of the reasons that our social security system exists is to support people whose health or disability makes everyday life harder, including many people living with mental illness.

We believe the social security system should help people thrive, support those who can work to do so, and provide security for those who cannot.

 

We know that mental illness first emerges in adolescence and early adulthood. Almost half of all lifelong mental health conditions start before the age of 18, and more than 62% before the age of 25. It’s very common that help only comes once someone’s mental health has seriously deteriorated and they’ve reached crisis point. By then they may have left work, dropped out of education or become isolated.

This autumn, two government reviews will help decide what our social security system looks like for years to come. The Milburn Review is looking at how more young people can get into education, training and work. The Timms Review is the government’s review of Personal Independence Payment (PIP).

We hear every day from people who want to build full lives, contributing to their communities however they are able to. What they need is a system that makes that ambition feel safe and possible. Welfare reform and employment support can help people build towards this, or it can make life harder for those who most need support.

We’ve seen how much is at stake. When the government moved to introduce significant changes to social security last year (known as the Pathways to Work proposals), people told us they were worried about the prospect of crude cuts, particularly the 4-point rule on PIP. Thankfully, the PIP cuts were withdrawn, but the uncertainty hasn’t gone away, and the Universal Credit health element was halved for new claimants.

Changes to address such complex issues cannot be based on one line, sticking plaster policies. From our work with people living with mental illness, and from the evidence gathered across our sector, we believe the test of these reviews is whether they help build trust.

This comes down to a few essential principles.

Support and opportunities that arrive in time

This conversation has been particularly centred around young people. At a time when nearly one million young people are not in education, employment or training, getting the right support in place early matters more than ever.

Young people who are out of work, training or education are repeatedly talked about as if they don’t want to work. We spoke to young people recently who told us a very different story. 77% of the young adults surveyed were actively looking for work, and most already had experience through jobs, volunteering or training. Most young people want what every generation has wanted – a decent job and a fair shot.

But many are trying to achieve that while managing significant mental health challenges. Three in four young people surveyed said their mental health affects their ability to look for work, and nine in ten feel stressed or anxious while job-hunting. Two-thirds of the young adults surveyed worried about the cost of travelling to interviews or support services. Some couldn’t afford the fare to an interview, missed it, and were then sanctioned by the Jobcentre. A system that punishes people for being unable to afford the bus to a job interview is working against its own goals.

Having the right support at the right time makes a difference. Earlier wraparound support can change that, helping people stay connected to the things that keep them well and making the future feel hopeful.

We also have to acknowledge that employment support and mental healthcare go hand in hand. No amount of employment support can succeed if someone is still waiting months, or even years, for the mental healthcare they need. In England alone, 1.8 million people are currently waiting to start community mental health treatment. For many people, finding work is made much harder by symptoms that could be reduced with timely support. For those severely affected by mental illness, work may not be realistic in the foreseeable future, and they they should not fear losing their social security. Any system that genuinely wants to help people thrive must begin by recognising these realities, and addressing mental health waiting lists and ensuring access to effective treatment is one of the pillars that makes sustainable participation possible.

When support is available, the impact can be life-changing. Young adults who had received the help they needed were far more confident about finding and keeping a job than those who hadn’t. The support they wanted most was one-to-one help from someone who would take time to know them and could work alongside them over time.

We want to see early and continuous wraparound support that starts with understanding the person in front of them. Person-focused support needs to understand where someone is in life, what matters to them, and what they want to achieve and address what’s getting in the way. It brings services together around a person instead of leaving them to find their way through disconnected systems on their own. That means the social security system working hand in hand with the NHS, social care, employment support and other services.

It was precisely because of this disconnect that we designed our Into Work Programme. Our programme shows what’s possible when you lean in, listen, then help. Stories like Chris’s show the difference this approach can make and the important role that the voluntary and community sector plays in building trusted relationships within local communities.

Help to find work can only go so far if the right opportunities aren’t there. National and local government should make sure their plans for growth, including the industrial strategy, create good, flexible and fairly paid jobs that are accessible for young people and disabled people. Employers should be empowered to recruit and meaningfully support employees living with mental illness by creating opportunities to develop and thrive.

An ambitious plan for the economy should be one that everyone can share in. Change can happen locally with national support and oversight. Mayors and councils are well placed to make sure different parts of the system talk to each other and work around the people who need them. We want to see local leaders take up that responsibility and be accountable to their communities.

Getting in early is one of the best investments any government can make. Early mental health support helps people stay connected to their education, work, families and communities. It prevents problems from becoming crises and strengthens the foundations for a good life. The result is not only better mental health but also stronger local communities and a healthier economy over the long-term too.

Getting better shouldn’t mean losing support

One of the clearest messages from Rethink Mental Illness’ Rethinking PIP report is that many people feel forced to choose between getting better and staying financially secure.

PIP pays for the things that help people recover, like therapy or a course. But when their claim is reviewed, those same activities can be taken as evidence that they no longer need support. We call this the recovery trap. The support that made recovery possible is removed because recovery happened, and people can end up back where they started.

“You then become too well for benefits, but it’s the benefits that are enabling you to be more well.” – Rethinking PIP expert by experience

The fear this creates changes how people live. One person was asked for their National Insurance number at an art therapy group and was later told the DWP knew they had been attending. They stopped going.

When people see support disappear as soon as they start to improve, trust breaks down. No one should have to hold themselves back from getting better.

The government’s Right to Try guarantee, which means people who try work or volunteering won’t have their benefits reviewed for trying, is a welcome start. But it doesn’t yet go far enough. The wider system also needs to recognise the recovery trap and ensure people aren’t penalised for taking positive steps or for simply living with an illness.

Recovery is rarely a straight line because there will always be times when someone is ready to take on more and times when their focus is on managing symptoms or getting treatment, or somewhere in between. What’s expected of people needs to reflect that. Sanctions should be a genuine last resort, with clear protections for anyone who is unwell. The focus should be on helping people engage, not on applying penalties that may push them further away from support and meaningful activities.

We’re highly concerned by reports that the Milburn Review is considering delaying access to UC health for young people, alongside a comprehensive package of support. We support efforts to provide earlier and more joined-up support, but support alone cannot overcome the barriers created by financial hardship. Just as employment support cannot succeed if someone is waiting months or years for mental health treatment, a new support offer cannot succeed if it leaves young people struggling to afford the essentials. Taking away that protection at the age when mental illness is most likely to emerge would make it much harder for young people to find their feet. Young people need financial security, timely mental health support, and a trusted person who can help them move forward at a pace that protects their wellbeing. The success of any new support offer will depend on its availability, quality and whether people feel able to trust it.

Any effective decisions on benefits needs to consider the reality of people’s experiences of their mental health, takes stock of the job market in terms of availability and appropriateness, has realistic time frames, and works to remove any barriers in place. This plan needs to be co-owned between the person and the case worker.

Trust is grounded in feeling safe

Before anyone can think about a job, a course or their future, they need to know that, right now and for the foreseeable future, they will be okay. They need to be able to afford the essentials and manage the extra costs that come with living with a mental illness.

Those costs can look very different from person to person. For one person it might be practical help to make daily life safer, and for another it might be additional heating costs from needing to stay home a lot, or the flexibility to take part in activities that support their recovery. People shouldn’t be asked to choose between meeting those costs and paying for the essentials, nor between financial support and the services that help them stay well. Money and services play different roles, so one cannot replace the other.

Money worries make mental health worse, and poor mental health makes money harder to manage. It’s very difficult to focus on getting better while worrying about rent, heating or food.

Benefits like PIP might pay for someone to get to their weekly therapy appointment when public transport isn’t an option or cover the practical help that stops a hard week from spiralling. It can help someone participate in the activities and support that helps their recovery. The people who contributed to the Rethinking PIP report talked about needing the right help in place so they can make their own choices and stand on their own two feet.

That same principle should shape how people experience our social security system itself. Time and again, people tell us that it doesn’t.

The system often meets people at some of the hardest moments of their lives. Assessments can mean describing painful, private experiences to a stranger, and then waiting weeks to find out whether you’ve been believed or understood. As one person said, “Never underestimate the breadth and depth of disbelief.” Young people describe similar experiences. Our research showed that only 13% of those surveyed, who had sought support from the system, said it had helped their wellbeing.

Part of the challenge is that mental illness, like many health conditions, does not fit neatly into a checklist. Assessments regularly miss the hidden effort of living with mental illness. Someone may technically be able to cook a meal or leave the house, but only after hours of building themselves up or receiving encouragement from someone, and it might come at a cost that leaves them unable to do anything else that day, week, or even month. Mental illness also fluctuates and varies hugely from person to person. Someone severely affected by anxiety & depression may be unable to leave their home and may not yet have been able to access treatment, while someone living with bipolar disorder may be feeling better than before because they have the right support in place.

A system that helps people feel safe would recognise these realities and prioritise safety as a means of building trust. People need to know that concerns will be taken seriously, that risks of harm will be identified and addressed, and that if things do go wrong, it will be properly investigated and there will be accountability.

Change people can believe in

Financial security, early support, and real opportunities to participate should reinforce one another. People are most able to participate when they have stability, so let’s give them that.

People living with mental illness know better than anyone that the current system needs to change. That’s why there is strong support for reform that makes things better for the people who rely on it. It needs to be built to last, rather than changing with every spending review.

As the Milburn and Timms reviews report, we’ll be looking for five core principles:

  1. Security
  2. Dignity
  3. Early, person-centred support
  4. Opportunity and choice
  5. Safety and accountability

If we get these principles right, then trust can follow – so can hope.

How you can help

We want to hear from you – your experiences shape everything we do and help us show decision-makers what needs to change by sharing your story.

End note: While we know that proposals from the Milburn Review and Timms Review will affect people England, we need greater clarity on plans for Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland.

Your donation will make the difference

Just £10 could allow 25 people to access the Mental Health & Money Advice website to help them improve their financial and mental health.

Donate today